Loggerhead Cay 574 [1]
Submitted by User One on
Unit Code: LC574*
Loggerhead Cay 574
Reviewed on 2026-03-30 by , Forest Park, IL UnknownOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
Beautiful unit, great location.
Manager's Response
Mary,
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. It's great to hear that you enjoyed your accommodations and time on the island. We look forward to hosting you with your future trips to Sanibel, Cheers!
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. It's great to hear that you enjoyed your accommodations and time on the island. We look forward to hosting you with your future trips to Sanibel, Cheers!
574 Loggerhead Cay
Reviewed on 2026-03-01 by , Plymouth, MN United StatesOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
Overall a nice condo and location to the beach. The supplies for kitchen/bathrooms were ok although with only a week stay it would be nice to have a few more essentials for the bathrooms.
Manager's Response
Don,
Thank you for taking the time to leave your review. We are happy that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead Cay & Sanibel Island. Unlike hotels, Sanibel Holiday manages privately owned condos and we supply "starter kits" for all our guests and communicate that in all our emails and text messages. It would be our pleasure to host your future visits to Sanibel!
Thank you for taking the time to leave your review. We are happy that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead Cay & Sanibel Island. Unlike hotels, Sanibel Holiday manages privately owned condos and we supply "starter kits" for all our guests and communicate that in all our emails and text messages. It would be our pleasure to host your future visits to Sanibel!
Loggerhead Cay 574
Reviewed on 2025-07-07 by William M. , Greer, SC USOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Very nicely furnished & comfortable. Nicely equipped for the beach & close. Sanibel Holiday was “Johnny on the spot”, helping in every way possible.
Manager's Response
William,
Thank you for taking the time to write a review. We and happy that you enjoyed the condo and the beach. We are always happy to assists our guests to make everything perfect for close to perfect! We hope you come back to visit again very soon, Cheers!
Thank you for taking the time to write a review. We and happy that you enjoyed the condo and the beach. We are always happy to assists our guests to make everything perfect for close to perfect! We hope you come back to visit again very soon, Cheers!
Great Holiday Vacation!
Reviewed on 2025-01-05 by , Deep River, CT USOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
We had a wonderful time here during the holidays! You can't beat the beach location. The unit is as pictured, clean - has all the things you need. The team at Sanibel Holiday were so helpful and kind. We would absolutely stay here again. Thank you so much!
Manager's Response
Hallie,
Thank you for leaving your review. We are happy to hear that you enjoyed your condo and stay on Sanibel. It will be a pleasure to host your future visits to Sanibel. Cheers, Team Sanibel Holiday
Thank you for leaving your review. We are happy to hear that you enjoyed your condo and stay on Sanibel. It will be a pleasure to host your future visits to Sanibel. Cheers, Team Sanibel Holiday
Return to Sanibel
Reviewed on 2024-08-26 by Kenneth L. , Louisville, KY United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Our experience with Sanibel holiday was exceptional. We had a three week stay and there were a few issues but all were handled immediately. Definitely recommend them for your Sanibel needs.
Manager's Response
Ken, Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. Thank you for being flexible with the unavoidable issue you experienced. It was a pleasure to host you and your family for you stay on Sanibel. We look forward to seeing you again next year!
Simply amazing
Reviewed on 2022-07-25 by Diana H. , Springfield, IL United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Loggerhead Cay 574 has it all. Great distance to beach and pool, beach cart, clean, updated bathrooms were a huge plus, beds and furniture were comfortable, etc. Will definitely be back...
Loggerhead cay
Reviewed on 2022-07-19 by , Okemos, MI United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Great stay
Great Place!
Reviewed on 2021-05-31 by Sara L. , SC United StatesOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
Loved visiting this condo. The only thing I wished was different was the key system used to get in and out of the condo. Seems dated at this point and would love for it to have been a keypad or something. It was fairly clean but there was some dog hair left behind. Overall, worth it!
Excellent vacation
Reviewed on 2021-05-08 by Aimee S. , Newbury, NH United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Sanibel holiday makes things so easy! The new key pick up and drop off location is great! Plenty of supplies to last us the week!
Nice property
Reviewed on 2021-04-19 by Onetta H. , Nixa, MO USOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
This was a nice condo and was in a good location. Beach towels and chairs provided which was great. Beautiful kitchen. The unit could use new living room furniture. It was not the most comfortable and it looked dirty. The unit was very clean other than the outside of the refrigerator/freezer door. It was not clean at all. Had trouble with the AC unit but management was looking into it Property managers were very friendly and helpful. There's not really a view of the ocean unless you stand at the edge of the screened in balcony, but it's a great view of the pool. We enjoyed our stay but it would be a nice improvement with new living room furniture.
Manager's Response
We appreciate you taking the time to provide us with and honest and thorough review of your recent stay at Loggerhead Cay 574. I will certainly pass along your review to the owner to see if new furniture is something they may want to consider. Loggerhead Cay is a larger property so there are many view options views, long views over the courtyard , strictly courtyard views and direct Gulf views which are at those units closest to the beach. What many love about Loggerhead Cay 574 is not only it's angled Gulf views over the pool but that this owner allows for dogs (under 25 lbs per Loggerhead Cay Association rules). While Sanibel itself is very dog friendly it is quite difficult to find a condo that allows them to stay. We hope your future travel plans bring you back to Sanibel and we would love the opportunity to find you the perfect accommodations for you and your family.
loggerhead Cay 574
Reviewed on 2021-03-29 by Richard B. , East Amherst, NY United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
we had a great week. very happy with the condo we rented.
loggerhead Cay 574
Reviewed on 2021-03-29 by Rick B. , East Amherst, NY United StatesOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
we had a great week. very happy with the condo we rented.
excellent location
Reviewed on 2020-12-28 by Kenneth D. , RI United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
A perfect spot on the beach (short walk). Not too far from many restaurants and shops.
Feng Shui in Sanibel
Reviewed on 2020-10-26 by Don & Caroline D. , Nicholasville, KY United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
One of the best feeling condos we've stayed in in Sanibel. Great floor plan. Nice and open, very inviting. Wonderful beds, very comfortable. Great master bath.
Manager's Response
We are thrilled you found every aspect of your recent stay at Loggerhead Cay 574 near perfect! Thank you for sharing the hightlights of this fantastic unit!
Loggerhead Cay 574
Reviewed on 2020-08-10 by Gwen T. , Summerville, SC United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Sanibel Island Beautiful as always! First time staying at Loggerhead Cay but we loved it! Unit itself needed dishwasher looked at but Sanibel Holiday was informed and I am sure it has been rectified!
Sanibel Holiday is amazing and every property we have rented thru them is always very suitable!
Sanibel Holiday is amazing and every property we have rented thru them is always very suitable!
Manager's Response
Thank you for the kudos for the Sanibel Holiday Team! Our guests are always our top priority. I did follow up on the dishwasher issue at #574 and that has been addressed. We hope to see you all again very soon!
Forth floor loggerhead cay
Reviewed on 2020-07-29 by Nick N. , West Frankfort, IL United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Excellent
Manager's Response
So many pluses to note about Loggerhead Cay 574! Top floor unit with amazing views of the Gulf as well as the beautiful pool and courtyard at Loggerhead Cay. This is also the most updated dog friendly (under 25 lbs) unit I have seen! It is also priced in line with units that are in the 3 and 4 building but offers Gulf views and great beach access! We hope your travel plans have you coming back soon!
Excellent stay
Reviewed on 2020-07-20 by , Cornelius, NC United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Great place, clean and comfortable.
Manager's Response
Thank you so much for your across the board 5 star review! We could not agree Cay #574 is great, clean and comfortable! We would also add very well priced for a Gulf-view unit and one of the most updated dog friendly (under 25 lbs) units we've seen! We hope you travel plans bring you back to Sanibel very soon!
Wonderful vacation
Reviewed on 2020-06-17 by Larry & Linda B. , Atlanta, GA United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
We were quite pleased with our condo. It was very clean and the bathrooms were beautifully updated. We loved the view from the 4th floor, but the elevator was broken for two days and going up and down the stairs multiple times a day was difficult at times. Other than that, our vacation experience was perfect.
Two weeks in Paradise
Reviewed on 2020-01-27 by , Tuckahoe, NY United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
We have come to Sanibel many times. This is a nice unit. The electric recliner is wonderful. I am getting one.
Sanibel Vacation
Reviewed on 2019-11-18 by Alan & Pauline M. , Rochester, NH United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Always an excellent time in Sanibel. We have been coming for almost 30 years and have stayed at many places on the island. Six years ago we dealt with Sanibel Holiday for the first time with a rental at Loggerhead Cay and enjoyed the service and property so much we simply renew with them each year. Always attentive and respond rapidly to any questions and concerns we have had. This was our first time at #574 but everything was as described, property clean, well maintained and excellent location in the complex. We asked for some additional beach chairs and Sanibel Holiday contacted the owner and they agreed and promptly provided them within less than half a day. We have already booked our stay for next year.
Manager's Response
Thank you so much for your 5 star review of your recent Loggerhead Cay 574 stay! We are thrilled that you had yet another excellent Sanibel visit! We really appreciate the Sanibel Holiday Staff shout-out! It's important to us that our guests know how much we value and appreciate them, we are so glad you noticed the LOVE! We can't wait to see you next year!!
July Vacation Rental
Reviewed on 2019-07-13 by Cheryl G. , Ocala, FL United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Loggerhead Cay #574 was a very clean, well-maintained property. Everything was as described. There were 6 of us staying at the condo, and the accommodations were sufficient. The view of the beach and pool area were viewable from the screened in porch. The property is located in a very quiet area, with great access to the beach. We would definitely rent this condo again when visiting Sanibel Island.
Great condo
Reviewed on 2019-05-20 by , Cornelius, NC United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Everything was great, we enjoyed it.
Superb Gulfside condo
Reviewed on 2019-04-22 by , Bracknell, BRK United KingdomOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
We have stayed in Loggerhead Cay a number of times and this condo was amongst the best. It’s beach side location is excellent and well placed for beautiful morning strolls, sunbathing and swimming. The condo is in great condition and Sanibel Holiday are an efficient and very friendly management company. We hope to be back!
Over due winter escape
Reviewed on 2019-03-22 by Deb M. , Henderson, KY United StatesOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
The folks at Sanibel Holiday were very respectful and accommodating from check-in to check-out. Provided all the information we needed and some good recommendations for restaurants, etc. in the area.
The condo was one of the nicest we've ever stayed in as far as comfort, cleanliness, and location to the beach. The beds were SO comfy, which means a lot to us! The condo was clean, even the floors (our socks did not get dirty walking around the condo)! We were very pleased at how quiet it was inside the condo. You can't hear your neighbors, vehicle noise, etc. Wonderfully upkept condo area with security and comfort!
The only problem we encountered was there was no beach chairs or umbrella in the condo. If it were not for the kindness of some people who had extras that they allowed us to borrow, we would not have been able to enjoy our relaxing days on the beach. (That is the only reason for the 4 stars under "amenities").
If you are looking for comfortable, relaxing, clean, quiet, safe beach vacation, we would highly recommend staying here.
Thanks again to the kindness of the folks who shared with us during our stay. LOVE SANIBEL!
The condo was one of the nicest we've ever stayed in as far as comfort, cleanliness, and location to the beach. The beds were SO comfy, which means a lot to us! The condo was clean, even the floors (our socks did not get dirty walking around the condo)! We were very pleased at how quiet it was inside the condo. You can't hear your neighbors, vehicle noise, etc. Wonderfully upkept condo area with security and comfort!
The only problem we encountered was there was no beach chairs or umbrella in the condo. If it were not for the kindness of some people who had extras that they allowed us to borrow, we would not have been able to enjoy our relaxing days on the beach. (That is the only reason for the 4 stars under "amenities").
If you are looking for comfortable, relaxing, clean, quiet, safe beach vacation, we would highly recommend staying here.
Thanks again to the kindness of the folks who shared with us during our stay. LOVE SANIBEL!
Loggerhead 574
Reviewed on 2019-03-11 by , Medina, MN United StatesOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
Loggerhead Cay is located in a great spot on the island. It is easy to bike to places and of course right on the beach. Staff needs to make sure kitchen is better supplied. It had very limited plates and utensils making it difficult to cook for a family of five. I did call to request a couple of items and the management company brought over items very quickly. Just expected the basic dishes would be there if they say it sleeps 6 people.
Happy and satisfied
Reviewed on 2018-06-28 by Mary K. , Munhall, PA United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
We stay every year for 4 weeks and always enjoy.We really like this pet friendly unit.....
Sanibel Oasis
Reviewed on 2018-04-13 by , North Merrick, NY United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
This was our first time staying in this unit at Loggerhead Cay and it won't be our last (we've already booked for next year). The proximity to the pool and the beach and the views were incredible. The unit felt beachy and warm and welcoming! Would recommend to friends (as long as they don't book our dates. Ha!)
Sanibel Holiday
Reviewed on 2018-04-13 by Steven S. , Chanhassen, MN United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Have rented many times from Sanibel Holiday and the staff especially Stephanie, who has been there for years, always makes us wanting to come back.
Sanibel Holiday
Reviewed on 2018-03-19 by Steven S. , Chanhassen, MN United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Have rented many times from Sanibel Holiday and the staff especially Stephanie, who has been there for years, always makes us wanting to come back.
Sanibel Oasis
Reviewed on 2017-09-02 by , North Merrick, NY United StatesOverall
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
This was our first time staying in this unit at Loggerhead Cay and it won't be our last (we've already booked for next year). The proximity to the pool and the beach and the views were incredible. The unit felt beachy and warm and welcoming! Would recommend to friends (as long as they don't book our dates. Ha!)
Great Vacation for all ages
Reviewed on 2017-04-03 by , Kildeer, IL United StatesOverall
Property condition
Location
Cleanliness
Services from rental manager
First time renting a condo and was very pleased. Nice, roomy and we all slept well. Room had high speed internet for my boys to play their online games which was key to our trip. Lovely location near the beach. Enjoyed my morning coffee on the lanai overlooking the pool with a hint of the beach in the background. The unit could be greatly improved with better/newer beach amenities such as beach umbrella, chairs and cart. I was envious of my friends unit which included Tommy Bahama beach chairs, umbrella and CART. Cart is key to haul all chairs, umbrella, drinks and towels to the beach in ONE trip. Also on the day we left, the dryer did not properly dry our beach towels.
Beds
- 1 King
- 2 Twins
- 1 Sofa Bed
OUTSIDE
- Lanai / Gazebo
- Outdoor Grill
- Tennis
- Fenced Pool
Area
- East End
View
- Gulf-View
ATTRACTIONS
- bay/sound
- botanical garden
- churches
- festivals
- library
- live theater
- marina
- museums
- playground
- recreation center
- restaurants
Complex
- Loggerhead Cay
Search Availability
Weekly Rental
Loggerhead Cay 574, Partial Angled Gulf View, Dog Friendly
LANAI WITH ANGLED GULF VIEW [3]
FRONT WALKWAY [4]
ENTRY DOOR VIEW [5]
KITCHEN [6]
KITCHEN [7]
KITCHEN [8]
KITCHEN [9]
DINING ROOM [10]
DINING ROOM [11]
DINING ROOM [12]
LIVING ROOM [13]
LIVING ROOM [14]
LIVING ROOM [15]
LIVING ROOM [16]
PRIMARY BEDROOM WITH KING BED [17]
PRIMARY BEDROOM WITH KING BED [18]
PRIMARY BEDROOM WITH KING BED [19]
PRIMARY BEDROOM WITH KING BED [20]
PRIMARY BATHROOM WITH WALK IN SHOWER [21]
PRIMARY BATHROOM WITH WALK IN SHOWER [22]
GUEST BEDROOM WITH 2 TWIN BEDS [23]
GUEST BEDROOM WITH 2 TWIN BEDS [24]
GUEST BEDROOM WITH 2 TWIN BEDS [25]
GUEST BATHROOM WITH TUB AND SHOWER COMBO [26]
GUEST BATHROOM WITH TUB AND SHOWER COMBO [27]
LAUNDRY AREA [28]
LANAI WITH POOL VIEW [29]
LANAI [30]
LANAI WITH POOL VIEW [31]
SHELL WASH STATION [32]
GAS GRILL BY BUILDING 5 [33]
HEATED POOL [34]
HEATED POOL [35]
POOL SEATING [36]
SHUFFLE BOARD [37]
SHUFFLE BOARD SEATING [38]
PICKLEBALL & TENNIS COURTS [39]
GAS GRILLS BY COURTS [40]
ENTRY [41]
ZEN GARDEN FOUNTAIN [42]
ZEN GARDEN SEATING [43]
LOCATION OF CONDO [44]
LOCATION OF CONDO [45]
AERIAL VIEW [46]
CHAIRS BY THE GULF [47]
SITE MAP [48]2 Bedrooms
2 Baths
Welcome to Loggerhead Cay 574, a beautifully appointed 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo that serves as a serene and sophisticated island oasis. Featuring warm coastal decor, high-end furnishings, and a layout designed for effortless relaxation, this elegant retreat boasts a private screened lanai with an angled partial view of the sparkling Gulf.
INTERIOR HIGHLIGHTS
~Fully Updated Kitchen: Equipped with everything you need to whip up quick beach snacks or multi-course gourmet dinners.
~Flexible Dining Options: Features a unique layout with a formal dining table seating 4, plus a charming kitchenette table for 2, perfect for morning coffee or a dedicated workspace.
~Inviting Living Room: Unwind on plush, comfortable seating arranged around a large flat-screen TV for relaxing movie nights.
LUXURIOUS SLEEPING QUARTERS & BATHS
~Primary Suite: A tranquil sanctuary featuring a premium King-size bed, a flat-screen TV, and a brand-new en-suite bathroom.
~Guest Suite: Ideal for family or friends, offering two cozy Twin beds, a flat-screen TV, and a beautifully remodeled private bathroom.
~Remote-Work Ready: Includes reliable high-speed Wi-Fi and internet for those who need to stay connected while on island time.
COMPLIMENTARY GEAR & RESORT AMENITIES
Skip the packing stress! The owner thoughtfully provides complimentary beach equipment for your short stroll to the sand.
~As a guest at Loggerhead Cay, you will enjoy premium community perks:
~Direct, effortless access to Sanibel’s white sandy beaches
~Oversized crystal-blue heated swimming pool (visible right from your lanai!)
~Pickleball, tennis, and shuffleboard courts
~Community gas grills throughout the complex & a dedicated shell-washing station
~Brand-new E-bike charging station in the rear parking lot
~Check-In: Skip the front desk with state-of-the-art secure, keyless entry via Wi-Fi-enabled smart locks (no key exchange required). Digital Guest Guide to help you throughout your stay & on-hand guest service from our Sanibel team.
PET POLICY
We welcome one dog (25 lbs or less) with a paid, non-refundable pet fee.
*This condominium requires a 7-night minimum stay SATURDAY TO SATURDAY BOOKINGS ONLY*
*Sleeper-sofa sheets available upon request*
*Sanibel Holiday cannot offer compensation or refunds due to closed amenities during your stay*
*This is a non-smoking property*
Sanibel Dwelling License #RDWL-005612
LocationField
- Sanibel Holiday
Location:
979 East Gulf Drive
33957
Sanibel
, FL
United States
26° 26' 18.33" N, 82° 2' 24.8892" W
See map: Google Maps [49]
Florida US
Location
- Sanibel Holiday