Loggerhead Cay 451 [1]
Family Vacation
Reviewed on 2026-06-29 by Susan K. , Dixon, IL United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for taking the time to write your review. We are happy to hear that you enjoyed the condo & Loggerhead Cay amenities. We look forward to hosting your future stays on Sanibel. Cheers!
Shelling 2026
Reviewed on 2026-05-17 by Danny S. , Raleigh, NC United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for taking the time to leave your review. I am so happy that you enjoyed your stay at Loggerhead cay 451 and all the amenities the owner offers. We thank you and look forward to having you back again, Cheers!
Paradise Revisited
Reviewed on 2026-05-03 by Laura M. , Duluth, GA United StatesManager's Response
vacation
Reviewed on 2025-12-18 by , United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for your review. We are very happy you enjoyed Loggerhead Cay 451 and the amenities offered. We work hard to keep it clean and offer everything a guest needs. We hope to host you again on your return trips to Sanibel, Cheers!
Ideal First Floor Sanibal Condo by the beach
Reviewed on 2025-12-16 by Mark T. , Baldwinsville, NY United StatesThis first-floor condo was absolutely perfect for our stay. Being just a short walk to the beach made our vacation incredibly easy and relaxing—no driving, no hassle, just grab your towel and go.
The condo itself was newly remodeled and spotless, comfortable, and beautifully maintained. Everything we needed was provided, from a well-equipped kitchen to comfortable beds and a welcoming living space. It truly felt like a home away from home.
One of the biggest highlights was Sanibel Island itself. The island-wide bike paths made it easy and enjoyable to explore everything at a relaxed pace, and it truly lives up to its reputation as the Seashell Capital of the World. We loved walking the beach and finding incredible shells just minutes from the condo. The bird sanctuary is a must see.
The location was quiet and peaceful, yet close to great restaurants, shopping, and local attractions.
The host was wonderful to work with—responsive, friendly, and made everything seamless.
We would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend this condo to anyone looking for a relaxing, convenient Sanibel Island vacation. An exceptional stay from start to finish!
Manager's Response
Thank you for your review. We are so happy that you enjoyed Loggerhead Cay 451 and Sanibel. We look forward to hosting you and Judy again, Cheers!
2026 Sanibel Vacation
Reviewed on 2025-09-14 by David E. , Waynesboro, PA United StatesWe would like to thank the owners again for coming over to clean up the water from the washer drain. We did add several ties to help keep the washer drain in place.
Manager's Response
Thank you for your review, we always welcome feedback from our guests. We will definitely consider higher beach chairs and a fan in the fining area. We also thank you for your patience with the washing machine issue and helping with the fix! We hope you come back and stay with us again, Cheers!
Highly recommend Sanibel Holiday property
Reviewed on 2025-07-27 by , Lakeland, FL United StatesManager's Response
It was a pleasure to have you and your family back again. We are thrilled that you enjoyed your condos and look forward to have you back as you are great guests!
Highly recommend Sanibel Holiday property
Reviewed on 2025-07-27 by Marlene F. , Lakeland, FL United StatesManager's Response
It was a pleasure to have you and your family back again. We are thrilled that you enjoyed your condos and look forward to have you back as you are great guests!
a relaxing week
Reviewed on 2025-07-10 by , Madison, NJ United StatesAfter the devastation from hurricane Ian in 2022 I feared I might never return to the island, but I was pleasantly surprised to see it coming back to life so quickly! It is an island still healing, but the beach is beautiful and still as magical as ever. Loggerhead Cay shows no signs of damage,
and is situated at a great location both close to the causeway and access to the main drag of Periwinkle where the restaurants and the grocery store are easily accessed. We were pleased that a couple of our favorite restaurants were open and we dined there several times, (Doc Fords and The Timbers). If you would prefer to eat in you could cook in the well supplied kitchen (which we did a couple of times). The unit has everything you need and feels like home away from home. The large TV in the living room was great for family viewing and the additional set in the master bedroom is an option as well. The double and single bed in the second bedroom is perfect for families.
We brought our small dog, and although the $300 non refundable pet deposit was a little steep for a 6 lb lap dog, I understand the policy. I just wish it was refundable upon seeing there was no damage.
I mentioned that the beach chairs were a bit shabby and they immediately responded that they would be replaced. This unit is a bit further back from the beach than our last two stays, so a beach cart would be useful.
I loved the floors in the condo, which can be easily swept. The appliances are new. I would suggest bringing your own washer pods as only two are provided and one needs to be used for the beach towels.
My family loves coming to Sanibel and we felt very comfortable in this unit, we will be back and return to this unit.
Manager's Response
Thank you so much for taking the time to leave a detailed review. We are happy that your favorite restaurants were open to dine in. We do mention in all our communications that we supply you with starter kits for dishwasher and washing machine and to bring more from home but since I own this unit I do leave extra pods under the sink and above the dishwasher for my guests. We do supply a beach cart to make it easy to walk to the beach and we replaced the broken beach chairs. I hope that you come back to visit us again soon, Cheers!
May holiday
Reviewed on 2025-06-01 by William N. , New Smyrna Beach, FL United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for your review. It was a pleasure having you as a guest. Please come back to stay with us soon!
Sister’s trip
Reviewed on 2025-05-05 by Cheryl M. , United StatesManager's Response
So happy to have you back at Loggerhead Cay 451. We are also happy to read that you enjoyed your stay. We look forward to hosting you and friends again for your future visits to Sanibel.
Loggerhead Cay
Reviewed on 2025-04-09 by K. , Webster Groves, Missouri United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for your review. It's always a pleasure to have you stay in our unit. So happy you enjoyed your time here!
Great vacation
Reviewed on 2025-03-31 by Rod S. , North Canton, OH United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for takin the time to leave a review on your stay with us. We are happy to hear that you enjoyed your accommodations, amenities and the island. I hope you will reach out the next time you return to Sanibel. Cheers!
Hurricane Milton shortens our trip
Reviewed on 2024-10-13 by Mike J. , Monclova, OH United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. I wish that Hurricane Milton hadn't spoiled your vacation and I hope you return to visit us very soon! We would be honor to have you back at Loggerhead Cay 451.
Loggerhead Cay 451
Reviewed on 2024-06-23 by Nathalie S. , Canandaigua, NY United StatesManager's Response
Beautiful condo in Paradise
Reviewed on 2024-06-09 by Stephanie R. , United StatesManager's Response
Thank you for taking the time to leave your kind review. It was a pleasure to have you and your mother stay with us and please do not hesitate to contact us for your future visits, Cheers!
Bob
Reviewed on 2024-01-21 by Marvin G. , Wichita, KS United StatesBob
Reviewed on 2024-01-21 by , Wichita, KS United StatesAwesome
Reviewed on 2022-10-10 by Kim B. , United StatesSanibel Holiday came through again!
Reviewed on 2022-09-26 by Mike J. , Monclova, OH United StatesA wonderful relaxing stay
Reviewed on 2022-06-15 by , Nashville, IN United StatesWonderful week
Reviewed on 2022-04-11 by Carol N. , United StatesSanibel Island 2022
Reviewed on 2022-02-27 by Tracey C. , Toledo, OH United StatesWe already have plans to return next year. We love it so much that we hope to make this our yearly vacation destination!
Sanibel Getaway
Reviewed on 2022-01-27 by Marvin G. , Wichita, KS United StatesBeautiful Location-Lovely, Well-Equipped
Reviewed on 2021-11-22 by Laura C. , United StatesLoggerhead Cay condo
Reviewed on 2021-10-04 by Keith M. , Webster Groves, MO United StatesGreat second stay
Reviewed on 2021-09-27 by Emily D. , United StatesGreat place
Reviewed on 2021-08-23 by Tatsiana S. , United StatesWonderful Family Vacation!
Reviewed on 2021-08-09 by Carmen G. , Coral Gables, FL United StatesParadise!!
Reviewed on 2021-07-05 by Michelle W. , Harrodsburg, KY United StatesGreat first floor stay
Reviewed on 2021-06-21 by , Miami, FL United StatesLove Loggerhead Cay in Sanibel
Reviewed on 2021-05-10 by James M. , United States2021 Sanibel Spring Getaway
Reviewed on 2021-05-03 by Jackie K. , Akron, OH United StatesManager's Response
Loggerhead Cay 451
Reviewed on 2021-03-23 by Signe W. , Chagrin Falls, OH United StatesSanibel Vacation
Reviewed on 2021-01-25 by Marvin G. , Wichita, KS United StatesLoggerhead Cay Unit 451
Reviewed on 2020-12-30 by Michael R. , Maple Plain, MN United StatesChristmas Reset
Reviewed on 2020-12-21 by Anthony A. , Hugo, MN United StatesManager's Response
Amazing!!
Reviewed on 2020-12-07 by Janice C. , Flat Rock, NC United StatesLoggerhead Cay 451
Reviewed on 2020-11-30 by Jennifer M. , United StatesPerfect Vacation Home
Reviewed on 2020-11-16 by , Chester, VA United StatesGreat experience
Reviewed on 2020-07-27 by Pam D. , Downingtown, PA United StatesManager's Response
Paridise
Reviewed on 2020-07-13 by Glen M. , Davenport, FL United Statesshelling 20@0
Reviewed on 2020-06-08 by Danny S. , Raleigh, NC United StatesClean, bright, family-friendly vacation rental
Reviewed on 2020-03-02 by Nicole H. , United Statessanibel
Reviewed on 2020-02-03 by Marvin G. , Wichita, KS United StatesLoggerhead Cay #451 condo
Reviewed on 2020-01-06 by , Greenville, PA United StatesSanibel Escape
Reviewed on 2019-12-16 by Joann S. , United StatesManager's Response
Sept 2019
Reviewed on 2019-09-23 by Danny S. , Raleigh, NC United StatesManager's Response
Sanibel in summer
Reviewed on 2019-08-19 by , Chicago, IL United StatesManager's Response
Family friendly and VERY CLEAN
Reviewed on 2019-07-20 by Cassie H. , Taylorsville, NC United StatesCongrats, you are going to Sanibel, don't be so fussy and enjoy!
Reviewed on 2019-06-24 by , Eleanor, WV United StatesGreat Place to Stay!
Reviewed on 2019-05-20 by Emily D. , United StatesLoggerhead Cay is fantastic
Reviewed on 2019-04-29 by Mike J. , Monclova, OH United StatesWonderful days in paradise
Reviewed on 2018-08-18 by Katja & Michael W. , Minden, NW United StatesWe enjoyed the pool area and were happy to use the barbecues close to the tennis courts.
The bathrooms and bed linen were spotlessly clean, the floors and kitchen could have been cleaned a bit better. All in all we had a wonderful time and would highly recommend this condo.
Excellent vacation
Reviewed on 2018-07-26 by Rita M. , Hatboro, PA United StatesAwesome vacation!
Reviewed on 2018-07-26 by , Townshend, VT United StatesGreat stay for our family
Reviewed on 2018-07-04 by William T. , Grantsburg, IL US451 Loggerhead Cay
Reviewed on 2018-04-18 by James S. , Boyne City, MI United StatesFamily Spring Break 2017
Reviewed on 2018-04-09 by Bryan R. , Middlebury, IN United StatesFabulous Stay at Loggerhead
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Angela T. , Sunrise, FL United StatesParadise
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by , Concord, NC United StatesSanibel Loggerhead Perfection
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Bruce O. , West Chester, OH United StatesTime to Relax in Peace
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Georgina T. , Tamarac, FL United StatesFamily Spring Break 2017
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Stephanie & Bryan R. , Middlebury, IN United StatesVacation
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Bambi M. , New Philadelphia, OH United StatesOur Third Annual Stay
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by , Weymouth, MA United StatesSanibel Love
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by , Miami, FL United StatesLoggerhead Cay always great!
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Steve R. , Harrison, AR United StatesSanibel Family Getaway
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by , Clear Lake, WI United StatesGreat Time
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Bruce O. , West Chester, OH United StatesJan. Vacation
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Peter G. , United StatesLoggerhead Cay Unit 451
Reviewed on 2018-04-06 by Tracy R. , Maple Plain, MN United StatesLoggerhead Cay Unit 451
Reviewed on 2018-03-12 by Mike & Tracy R. , Maple Plain, MN United StatesLoggerhead Cay Unit 451
Reviewed on 2018-03-12 by Tracy R. , Maple Plain, MN United StatesLoggerhead Cay Unit 451
Reviewed on 2018-03-12 by Michael R. , Maple Plain, MN United StatesJan. Vacation
Reviewed on 2018-02-19 by Peter G. , United StatesLoggerhead Cay always great!
Reviewed on 2018-01-30 by Steve R. , Harrison, AR United StatesGreat Time
Reviewed on 2018-01-30 by Bruce O. , West Chester, OH United StatesSanibel Family Getaway
Reviewed on 2017-12-09 by , Clear Lake, WI United StatesSanibel Love
Reviewed on 2017-11-18 by Margarita T. , Miami, FL United StatesParadise
Reviewed on 2017-10-24 by Kaye O. , Concord, NC United StatesVacation
Reviewed on 2017-07-31 by Bambi M. , New Philadelphia, OH United StatesGreat stay
Reviewed on 2017-06-19 by , Flowery Branch, GA United StatesGreat stay
Reviewed on 2017-06-19 by Veronica B. , United StatesTime to Relax in Peace
Reviewed on 2017-06-15 by Georgina T. , Tamarac, FL United StatesFamily Spring Break 2017
Reviewed on 2017-04-30 by Bryan R. , Middlebury, IN United StatesThe perfect relaxing vacation!
Reviewed on 2017-04-24 by Ana & Gregory H. , Rochester, MA United StatesOur Third Annual Stay
Reviewed on 2017-03-20 by , Weymouth, MA United StatesSanibel Loggerhead Perfection
Reviewed on 2017-01-30 by Bruce O. , West Chester, OH United StatesBeds
- 1 King
- 1 Queen
- 1 Twin
- 1 Sofa Bed
OUTSIDE
- Lanai / Gazebo
- Lawn / Garden
- Outdoor Grill
- Tennis
- Fenced Pool
Area
- East End
View
- Courtyard/Garden
ATTRACTIONS
- bay/sound
- churches
- festivals
- library
- live theater
- marina
- museums
- playground
- pond
- recreation center
- restaurants
Complex
- Loggerhead Cay
Search Availability
Loggerhead Cay #451: Ground-Level Coastal Oasis | Steps to Pool & Beach!
LANAI AND PRIMARY BEDROOM [3]
KITCHEN [4]
KITCHEN [5]
KITCHEN [6]
KITCHEN [7]
KITCHEN [8]
LIVING ROOM [11]
LIVING ROOM [12]
LIVING ROOM [13]
PRIMARY BEDROOM [17]
PRIMARY BATHROOM [18]
GUEST BEDROOM WITH QUEEN AND TWIN [19]
GUEST BEDROOM WITH QUEEN AND TWIN [20]
GUEST BATHROOM [22]
laundry [23]
BEACH TOWELS [24]
LANAI WITH BEACH EQUIPEMENT [25]
LANAI & PRIMARY BEDROOM [26]
ROCKING ON THE LANAI [27]
LANAI [28]
VIEW FROM LANAI TO POOL & GULF [29]
GAS GRILL BY BUILDING #5 [30]
GAS GRILL NEXT TO COURTS [31]
HEATED POOL [32]
HEATED POOL [33]
POOL SEATING [34]
PICKLEBALL & TENNIS COURTS [35]
SHUFFLE BOARD [36]
SHUFFLE BOARD SEATING [37]
SHELL WASH STATION [38]
ENTRY [39]
ZEN GARDEN FOUNTAIN [40]
ZEN GARDEN SEATING [41]
GARDEN SEATING [42]
Chairs at Gulf [43]
location [44]
location [45]
AERIAL VIEW [46]
site map [47]Welcome to Loggerhead Cay 451, a premium, fully renovated ground-level condominium that defines coastal modern luxury. Rebuilt with high-end upgrades—including sparkling quartz countertops, porcelain wood-plank flooring, and custom tile work—this 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom retreat comfortably accommodates up to 6 guests.
STANDOUT FEATURES
~True Ground-Floor Freedom: Step directly out from your private, screened-in lanai for steps-away access to the resort pool and the Gulf.
~No-See-Um Protection: The spacious lanai is equipped with specialized no-see-um screening, letting you enjoy the warm Gulf breezes in total comfort day or night.
~Open-Concept Living: A fully equipped chef's kitchen with a dual Keurig drip or pod coffee maker, plenty of dishware. The kitchen flows seamlessly into a dedicated dining space and a bright living area, complete with a Queen sofa sleeper for extra guests.
BOUTIQUE SLEEPING QUARTERS (Sleeps 6)
~Primary Suite: A serene sanctuary featuring a premium King bed, a flat-screen TV with Netflix capability, and a private en-suite bathroom.
~Guest Suite: A clever and quaint layout offering one Queen bed and one Twin bed, paired with a bathroom featuring a modern walk-in shower.
️THE ULTIMATE BEACH KIT (Included with Your Stay)
Skip the heavy packing! The owners have provided everything you need for the perfect day on the sand:
~4 Premium beach chairs & large umbrella
~Heavy-duty beach cart & cooler
~6 plush beach towels
RESORT AMENITIES & LOCATION
Perfectly situated near the Sanibel Causeway and the vibrant boutiques and dining of Periwinkle Way, the family-friendly Loggerhead Cay complex offers:
~Oversized crystal-blue heated swimming pool
~Pickleball, tennis, and shuffleboard courts
~Community gas grills throughout the complex & a dedicated shell-washing station
~Brand-new E-bike charging station in the rear parking lot
SEAMLESS BOOKING & ARRIVAL WITH SANIBEL HOLIDAY
~Managed by Sanibel Holiday, your trip begins the moment you pull into the driveway. Skip the check-in office entirely—this unit features the latest Wi-Fi-enabled smart locks.
~Your family will receive a single, highly secure, personalized access code for total peace of mind throughout your stay. A Digital Guest Guide to help you throughout your stay & on-hand guest service from our Sanibel team.
PET POLICY
We welcome one dog (25 lbs or less) with a paid, non-refundable pet fee.
*7 night minimum stay required
*Sleeper sofa sheets available upon request only*
*Sanibel Holiday cannot offer compensation or refunds due to closed amenities during your stay*
*This is a non-smoking property*
*Sanibel Dwelling License #RDWL-009338
LocationField
- Sanibel Holiday
Location
- Sanibel Holiday
